Adam Bongers

Education Researcher and Lecturer

I lecture and research in education at UNSW Sydney. I draw on over two decades of experience in Australia and Japan, of teaching, training teachers, and managing language and vocational colleges.

Educational Administration Theory

My work sits in the tradition of educational administration theory. This tradition aims at a coherent understanding of (1) leadership: what initiatives we implement, (2) organisation: where we implement them, and (3) knowledge: how we evaluate their implementation.

My evolving view is that educational administration has concentrated on leadership, while leaving questions about organisation and especially knowledge underexplored.

Theory’s main task is not to provide a model of ‘what we know,’
Rather, theory’s main task is to outline ‘how we come to know’ what we do.

Reconstructive Epistemology

My project has been to reconstruct the theory of organisation and, particularly, theory of knowledge that goes unsaid in educational leadership. But theories of organisation and knowledge don’t go away just because we don’t talk about them.

My main contention is that today’s form of educational leadership (‘leader influence’) is informed by a different theory of knowledge compared to past educational administration research. If we don’t appreciate this, both researchers and critics will be blind to how contemporary educational leadership really operates.

To figure out what kind of theory of knowledge is active today, I take an approach that I call reconstructive epistemology. It’s rooted in traditions of comparative epistemology (Fleck, 1979) and historical epistemology (Foucault in Canguilhem, 1978).

I examine research, policy, and practical texts to reconstruct the objects (Daston, 2000; Rheinberger, 1997) and styles of inquiry (Crombie,1994; Hacking, 2009; Lloyd, 2004). Style is something which can function when the method is not yet there (paraphrase of Masterman, 1970).

I describe my approach as figuring out people’s revealed epistemology, or: what people were looking for, judging by the way they went about it. It’s important that I say ‘looking for,’ not ‘looking at:’

Styles of inquiry are not different ways of looking at the same thing.
Rather, styles of inquiry look for different things.

I’ve been using this approach to make sense of past research, but it also promises to make sense of live educational settings as they operate in the present.

Take, for example, a situation where initiatives and interventions do not seem to be achieving their stated aims. Rather than starting with those aims, this approach starts with the practices themselves and works backwards. It asks what particular framing of the problem, and what sorts of evidence, those practices presuppose.

The point is that, even if these practices are not achieving their stated aims, they are still doing something. They are organised around some understanding of the problem, drawing on some sorts of evidence, and producing some sorts of outcomes. The task is to work out what those are, rather than assume that the stated aims tell us what is actually going on.

Questions and Answers (so far)

Here are some of the questions that I’ve been working on, and some of the answers I’ve arrived at:

  1. How can we know the philosophy that underpins educational leadership research?
    Even if mainstream researchers don’t spell out their object and style of inquiry, we can still reconstruct them from the traces they leave behind, even if that means continually revising as we go along.

Bongers, A. (2026). Feeling the way in the dark: Archaeological research in educational leadership. In R. Niesche & D. Mifsud (Eds.), Thinking with Michel Foucault in educational leadership (pp. 47–74). Bloomsbury. https://doi.org/10.5040/9781350471917.ch-2

Themes: what people were looking for, judging by the way they went about it;
an object of inquiry as marking out the unknown as something knowable (worth knowing but not-yet known).
[PDF]

  1. Why has educational administration narrowed inquiry to leader influence?
    A clue lies in the relationship between the object that inquiry is looking for, and the style of looking for it. If we have relied on survey questionnaires of staff perceptions and attitudes, it is little wonder that we have concentrated on influence over staff perceptions and attitudes.

Bongers, A. (2025). The leaderisation of schools: how did schooling come to be about leadership? [Commentary]. Leading & Managing, 31(3), 135-139. https://journals.flvc.org/leading-and-managing/issue/view/6569

Themes: leadership influence as tilting staff perceptions and attitudes to build commitment to a vision or mission of change;
better leadership theory, or something better than leadership theory.
[PDF]

  1. What is the style of inquiry in today’s educational leadership research?
    We choose evidence that is consistent with what (we think) we know, based on past survey questionnaire studies. But consistency cannot be our only criterion. We need to consider other bodies of evidence, and other criteria for choosing between explanations.

Bongers, A. (2026). Bringing back theory choice: comparative epistemology in educational administration and leadership research. Journal of Educational Administration and History. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220620.2026.2732910

Themes: what questions get posed and what counts as a valid answer.
[PDF]

  1. How does this style of inquiry play out? What is the mechanism?
    These days, what (we think) we know is consolidated through overviews of existing research. But the way we construct those overviews introduces its own issues. I examine a prominent paper making ‘seven strong claims’ about leadership and identify seven methodological pressure points.

Bongers, A. (2026). Overviews and intellectual authority in educational leadership research: How we know ‘what we know.’ Educational Management Administration & Leadership. https://doi.org/10.1177/17411432261495221

Themes: not just what we know, but how we came to know it;
the evidence that goes into evidence-informed practice.
[PDF]


Contact

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨


References

Crombie, A. C. (1994). Styles of scientific thinking in the European tradition: The history of argument and explanation especially in the mathematical and biomedical sciences and arts (Vols. 1–3). Duckworth.

Daston, L. (Ed.). (2000). Biographies of scientific objects. University of Chicago Press.

Fleck, L. (1979). Genesis and development of a scientific fact. University of Chicago Press.

Foucault, M. (1978). Introduction by Michel Foucault. In G. Canguilhem, On the normal and the pathological (p. ix-xx). D. Reidel Publishing.

Hacking, I. (2009). Scientific reason. National Taiwan University.

Lloyd, G. E. R. (2004). Ancient worlds, modern reflections: Philosophical perspectives on Greek and Chinese science and culture. Clarendon Press.

Masterman, M. (1970). The nature of a paradigm. In I. Lakatos & A. Musgrave (Eds.), Criticism and the growth of knowledge: Proceedings of the International Colloquium in the Philosophy of Science, London, 1965 (pp. 59–90). Cambridge University Press.

Rheinberger, H.-J. (1997). Toward a history of epistemic things: Synthesizing proteins in the test tube. Stanford University Press.